The Cradle
Baby Names   |   Weekly Pregnancy Calendar   |   Expert Pregnancy Advice   |   Baby Product Guide
Sign In    Join  |  Home  |  About Us  |  Link to Us   
 

W

ee

k

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

22

24

26

28

30

32

34

36

38

40
MY CRADLE   |   MESSAGE BOARDS   |   MY WEB PAGE   |   GROUPS

Categories » Labor & Delivery » Home Birth

Home Birth
    Messages 1 - 15 (20 total)     Next>>     Last
snowball164

Rank: out of the nursery
Posts: 134
Joined: 6/16/08
Full Term
Home Birth | 11/7/08 3:46 AM
Sorry So Long but...

OK. So my best friend was pregnant with her first child, due this last October. She had told me months before that she was planning on delivering at home with a midwife.
I said to her (as a experienced mother of 2 myself), "Wow, you are brave for trying a home birth with your first child...without knowing how you will do with labor." And she politely said "I think you're brave for going to hospitals." We laughed and went on.
As I just discovered we're pregnant with our 3rd I thought about doing a home birth too, until..
She called me yesterday and told me that she was sorry for not calling for a month. (i knew she went into labor on Oct 11) But she delivered her son on the 11th and he wasn't breathing.
During her labor, the cord got pinched...but since she was at home and couldn't monitor the baby's status -they had no clue. So they rushed the baby to 2 hospitals and by then, there was too much brain damage for the boy to function...so he died on the 13th.

This freaked me out and I'm starting to reconsider home births.
Also while I was researching water home births..I read many stories of women who have done this. And one lady had already lost one child in a home birth and was doing it for a second time...in which the baby almost died because of breathing issues. I just don't get it.

What do you ladies think? Anyone tried home births?
Mom4

Rank: sprout
Posts: 55
Joined: 3/30/08
Full Term
RE: Home Birth | 11/7/08 4:30 AM as a reply to snowball164.
While it might sound nice, I would never do it. How awful to carry a healthy baby to term and then loose it when a hospital would of had the knowledge to prevent it from happening in the first place. I couldn't take a chance. My heart goes out to your friend. I have heard good things about home births as well, maybe this midwife wasn't as qualified as she should have been and maybe she could have caught it early enough. I know how scary and sterile hospitals are but they are the place that are best prepared if anything unscene comes along in your pregancy. Why take a chance.
sesa

Rank: seedling
Posts: 29
Joined: 3/13/08
Full Term
RE: Home Birth | 11/7/08 6:33 PM as a reply to snowball164.
An at home birth done correctly and with the right midwife should have been monitoring the baby- in my opinion. I have had two home births- both times my babies were monitored routinely with doplar and not only that, my midwifes training allowed her to hear cord sounds, placenta sounds, my sounds,vs baby heartbeat- something no hospital staff is trained in. In interviewing midwives, I did come across one in our area that is very non-interventionist in style, no monitoring, just there to catch the baby. I would not be comfortable with that- so I went with the midwife that is licensed to draw blood, give IV if needed, sew me up after, administer the numbing injections for the tear repair etc. she even does the after care with baby, the PKU etc...
There are plenty of hospital birth stories as well...do some research on statistical outcomes on both and make your decision after doing so and after interviewing your local options for midwives.

 

 

RE: Home Birth | 11/7/08 7:24 PM as a reply to snowball164.
snowball164:
Sorry So Long but...

OK. So my best friend was pregnant with her first child, due this last October. She had told me months before that she was planning on delivering at home with a midwife.
I said to her (as a experienced mother of 2 myself), "Wow, you are brave for trying a home birth with your first child...without knowing how you will do with labor." And she politely said "I think you're brave for going to hospitals." We laughed and went on.
As I just discovered we're pregnant with our 3rd I thought about doing a home birth too, until..
She called me yesterday and told me that she was sorry for not calling for a month. (i knew she went into labor on Oct 11) But she delivered her son on the 11th and he wasn't breathing.
During her labor, the cord got pinched...but since she was at home and couldn't monitor the baby's status -they had no clue. So they rushed the baby to 2 hospitals and by then, there was too much brain damage for the boy to function...so he died on the 13th.

This freaked me out and I'm starting to reconsider home births.
Also while I was researching water home births..I read many stories of women who have done this. And one lady had already lost one child in a home birth and was doing it for a second time...in which the baby almost died because of breathing issues. I just don't get it.

What do you ladies think? Anyone tried home births?



Hello,
I am Cate Cradle, a member of the Cradle team. Congratulations to all of you on your pregnancies and/or new babies! I would like to suggest an article that may be helpful with this particular topic:

Different Birthing Options
snowball164

Rank: out of the nursery
Posts: 134
Joined: 6/16/08
Full Term
RE: Home Birth | 11/8/08 4:11 AM as a reply to sesa.
sesa:
An at home birth done correctly and with the right midwife should have been monitoring the baby- in my opinion. I have had two home births- both times my babies were monitored routinely with doplar and not only that, my midwifes training allowed her to hear cord sounds, placenta sounds, my sounds,vs baby heartbeat- something no hospital staff is trained in. In interviewing midwives, I did come across one in our area that is very non-interventionist in style, no monitoring, just there to catch the baby. I would not be comfortable with that- so I went with the midwife that is licensed to draw blood, give IV if needed, sew me up after, administer the numbing injections for the tear repair etc. she even does the after care with baby, the PKU etc...
There are plenty of hospital birth stories as well...do some research on statistical outcomes on both and make your decision after doing so and after interviewing your local options for midwives.


Very Interesting. About the midwife hearing the cord and placenta and all. That could have made a difference. I feel so bad for my friend, and it kind of scared me away from this idea. But there are so many success stories as well. Like your own.
I did my first two babies in the hospital.(both un-medicated) First one was normal.(with all the IVs and hooked up to every machine) The second one I tried the birthing tubs and chose to not have anything stuck in me...so it was like all natural but just in the security of a hospital.
We'll see what my options are with this third. We've moved states so I don't know what is available as far as midwives and water birthing.

Thank you for your responses. It helps to hear that it can be totally safe.
I was just in a bit of shock when my friend called me.
-Snow
vhunt1973

Rank: bean
Posts: 5
Joined: 11/14/08
Full Term
RE: Home Birth | 11/15/08 2:49 AM as a reply to sesa.
I agree with Sesa. I have one child, born at home successfully and I am planning another in June. Wouldn't do it any other way. However, I chose that option because that is where I felt myself and my baby would be safest. My midwife monitored the baby all the way through my labor, especially during pushing...she had the doppler on me constantly. She is also trained in giving life saving treatments if needed. Research, research, research!! Don't just go with what friends, your mother, or even doctor say. Trust that you have done all the right research to make an informed decision.

 

 

snowball164

Rank: out of the nursery
Posts: 134
Joined: 6/16/08
Full Term
RE: Home Birth | 11/17/08 9:39 PM as a reply to vhunt1973.
Thank you soo much ladies. I was so scared for a while about this issue. This being my third baby I want to do the home birth. I have a long time to think about it...and like you said Research.
clothdipes4us

Rank: bean
Posts: 2
Joined: 11/20/08
Full Term
RE: Home Birth | 11/20/08 7:50 PM as a reply to snowball164.
I think there are good and bad for all births. I, myself will never give birth, in a hospital again, if it can be avoided. I had 2 hospital births for my 2 oldest children, and it was horrid. being tied to a bed, is not natural for birthing. Plus my second daughter contracted RSV at the hospital, and wound up back at less than 2 weeks old, for over a week. It was scary.
My 3rd was born at a birth center, and it was very nice. Except, i labored at home for 27 hours, went to the birth center, had the baby a couple hours later, and left 2 hours after that. Why did i feel the need for the car ride mid labor??
I have also had 2 stillborn children born at home. We knew they had died, before the birth, and i chose to keep on with my plans to have the babies at home. It was a very intimiate situation, and i had wonderful peaceful births with them. I would not have wanted a bunch of strangers around me then.
I am now pregnant again, planning another homebirth, no matter the outcome of this pregnancy. Unless i have my 20 week US that shows there is something wrong with the baby, that would warrant a hospital birth. My midwife is well trained and i LOVE her. She is an amazing woman.
I feel, in general, the medical community tries to scare women from having home births. But really, homebirths have been aruond since the beginning of man. yes some babies die., yes some moms die, but generally there are more complications with hospital births, becasue of all of the interventions. If you dont Dilate fast enough, they want to give you pit, which then leads to epidural and or, over stimulation, fetal heart drop, then forecep delivery, or c section, that would not have had to happen, if the mom was allowed to labor as her body would labor.
Anyway, guess i could write a book on the subject. I just really wish ppl would not be so afraid of what they dont understand, and that people were not so quick to judge, when something does go wrong.
treeoflife

Rank: bean
Posts: 3
Joined: 1/18/09
Full Term
RE: Home Birth | 1/23/09 4:50 AM as a reply to sesa.
Thank you sesa for the reality check on the home "birth horror story". It is safer then being in a germ infested hospital with people who want to intervene in your birth and take away from the experience. Static's speak for themself, if women actually looked at the horrible (unnecessary) things that happen to moms and babies every day in a hospital they would never give birth there. But most of all a qualified midewife with the training and equipment is just responsible. I personally have had 2 lay midwives and we did have a few challanges and they handled them totally profesionally and without alarm.

 

 

snowball164

Rank: out of the nursery
Posts: 134
Joined: 6/16/08
Full Term
RE: Home Birth | 2/17/09 12:18 PM as a reply to treeoflife.
So we are 20 weeks now. And we found out it's a girl and everything is fine and healthy. So we are actually considering going for the home birth.
I agree about being strapped to the bed at the hospital. That's what happened with my first.
Then I found out...I have options! With my second child...I told them I didn't want to be hooked up for anything I want to walk around my room and use the birthing tubs.(check with your hospitals about these options)
My second birth was soooo much more enjoyable. Perfect.

So I want to do the homebirth and make it even more intimate and special (to me).
StellaZ

Rank: seedling
Posts: 38
Joined: 1/4/09
Full Term
RE: Home Birth | 2/20/09 9:53 AM as a reply to snowball164.
I am shocked that midwife is allowed to practice. I smell lawsuit. Any certified midwife nowadays should have all the basic tools on hand for a birth, just like a hospital (oxygen, fetal monitor, drugs etc). It's not like it used to be at all. Then if there are complications you always have a hospital backup plan for longer term care if needed.

I plan on doing a waterbirth with my midwife/RN group at the hospital clinic - connected to the hospital. This is my first (and probably only) and I would love the idea of a home birth, but with a paramedic father and an RN mother, I can't comfortably go without the medical side entirely. But I can tell you I won't be lying down while the doctor is sitting b/c its more comfortable for them - or get a petocin shot to speed things up so they can get home for dinner!

Watch the documentary "The Business of Being Born" - fascinating stuff!
babyward3

Rank: bean
Posts: 3
Joined: 2/20/09
Full Term
RE: Home Birth | 2/20/09 2:15 PM as a reply to snowball164.
Home births can be nice if you have a well trained, experienced, licensed mid-wife, but I dont think I'd do it personally. I have 2 children, both delivered without a problem and came quite quickly, so I'm a little worried my 3rd may come before I make it to the hospital, but I'm going anyway. The hospital has so many tools immediately available for anything unexpected that it makes me feel safer, plus I enjoy not having to worry about cleaning up afterword or what I'm having for dinner. It's nice to be taken care of for a couple days.

 

 

L&D nurse

Rank: bean
Posts: 6
Joined: 4/9/09
RE: Home Birth | 4/10/09 12:49 PM as a reply to snowball164.
snowball164:
sesa:
An at home birth done correctly and with the right midwife should have been monitoring the baby- in my opinion. I have had two home births- both times my babies were monitored routinely with doplar and not only that, my midwifes training allowed her to hear cord sounds, placenta sounds, my sounds,vs baby heartbeat- something no hospital staff is trained in. In interviewing midwives, I did come across one in our area that is very non-interventionist in style, no monitoring, just there to catch the baby. I would not be comfortable with that- so I went with the midwife that is licensed to draw blood, give IV if needed, sew me up after, administer the numbing injections for the tear repair etc. she even does the after care with baby, the PKU etc...
There are plenty of hospital birth stories as well...do some research on statistical outcomes on both and make your decision after doing so and after interviewing your local options for midwives.


Very Interesting. About the midwife hearing the cord and placenta and all. That could have made a difference. I feel so bad for my friend, and it kind of scared me away from this idea. But there are so many success stories as well. Like your own.
I did my first two babies in the hospital.(both un-medicated) First one was normal.(with all the IVs and hooked up to every machine) The second one I tried the birthing tubs and chose to not have anything stuck in me...so it was like all natural but just in the security of a hospital.
We'll see what my options are with this third. We've moved states so I don't know what is available as far as midwives and water birthing.

Thank you for your responses. It helps to hear that it can be totally safe.
I was just in a bit of shock when my friend called me.
-Snow


Let me make this clear...hospital staff are highly trained to know the difference between the mother's heartbeat and the fetal heartbeat. There is no such thing as "cord sounds". But if you're referring to a deceleration in the baby's heartbeat due to cord compression, nurses are also trained to know when that is happening. It's a certain pattern in the deceleration that would indicate that, and certain interventions they would take to relieve the cord compression.
snowball164

Rank: out of the nursery
Posts: 134
Joined: 6/16/08
Full Term
RE: Home Birth | 4/12/09 11:17 PM as a reply to StellaZ.
StellaZ:
I am shocked that midwife is allowed to practice. I smell lawsuit. Any certified midwife nowadays should have all the basic tools on hand for a birth, just like a hospital (oxygen, fetal monitor, drugs etc). It's not like it used to be at all. Then if there are complications you always have a hospital backup plan for longer term care if needed.

I plan on doing a waterbirth with my midwife/RN group at the hospital clinic - connected to the hospital. This is my first (and probably only) and I would love the idea of a home birth, but with a paramedic father and an RN mother, I can't comfortably go without the medical side entirely. But I can tell you I won't be lying down while the doctor is sitting b/c its more comfortable for them - or get a petocin shot to speed things up so they can get home for dinner!

Watch the documentary "The Business of Being Born" - fascinating stuff!



Ok. So I just recently watched this movie on Netflix after your suggestion...it *is* very interesting!

I would recommend this movie to all preggos.

It gives you the facts and statistics of Home births vs hospital births. It also talks about the interventions in hospitals that actually cause more problems than helps. And increases the c-section rate in our country.

It definitely reports about how hospitals want ladies in and out as quickly as possible even if that means to up the pitocin and cause fetal heart rate to increase which ends in a c-section.

Ricki Lake is in it...and it follows her through her birthing experience.

Check it out ladies.
L&D nurse

Rank: bean
Posts: 6
Joined: 4/9/09
RE: Home Birth | 4/16/09 12:52 AM as a reply to snowball164.
snowball164:
StellaZ:
I am shocked that midwife is allowed to practice. I smell lawsuit. Any certified midwife nowadays should have all the basic tools on hand for a birth, just like a hospital (oxygen, fetal monitor, drugs etc). It's not like it used to be at all. Then if there are complications you always have a hospital backup plan for longer term care if needed.

I plan on doing a waterbirth with my midwife/RN group at the hospital clinic - connected to the hospital. This is my first (and probably only) and I would love the idea of a home birth, but with a paramedic father and an RN mother, I can't comfortably go without the medical side entirely. But I can tell you I won't be lying down while the doctor is sitting b/c its more comfortable for them - or get a petocin shot to speed things up so they can get home for dinner!

Watch the documentary "The Business of Being Born" - fascinating stuff!



Ok. So I just recently watched this movie on Netflix after your suggestion...it *is* very interesting!

I would recommend this movie to all preggos.

It gives you the facts and statistics of Home births vs hospital births. It also talks about the interventions in hospitals that actually cause more problems than helps. And increases the c-section rate in our country.

It definitely reports about how hospitals want ladies in and out as quickly as possible even if that means to up the pitocin and cause fetal heart rate to increase which ends in a c-section.

Ricki Lake is in it...and it follows her through her birthing experience.

Check it out ladies.



ever think that those babies that are born via c-section may have been the ones that would have died at home? you can have a hospital delivery with a midwife, and they can be very accomodating to a "home birth" or even water birth experience, but the backup is always just around the corner. you never know what could go wrong
    Messages 1 - 15 (20 total)     Next>>     Last